What are the top rated Pet Friendly Vacation Rentals in New Carlisle?

There are a lot of options in New Carlisle. If you plan on staying in the New Carlisle area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Pet Friendly Vacation Rentals in New Carlisle: <a href="/property/home-w-king-suite-4-mins-to-day-airport/HA-3213925865" class="class="static-page-link"">Home w/King Suite 4 Mins to DAY Airport</a> <a href="/property/big-blue-on-4th/HA-3214311898" class="class="static-page-link"">Big Blue on 4th!</a> <a href="/property/cozy-bungalow-near-downtown-and-wittenberg/HA-3213999675" class="class="static-page-link"">Cozy Bungalow near downtown and Wittenberg</a> <a href="/property/a-unique-creekside-getaway-for-families-friends/HA-3214433012" class="class="static-page-link"">A Unique Creekside Getaway for Families &amp; Friends</a> <a href="/property/dayton-area-family-retreat-kids-ready-pet-friendly/HA-3214795962" class="class="static-page-link"">Dayton Area Family Retreat: Kids‑Ready &amp; Pet‑Friendly</a> <a href="/property/cheerful-3-bedroom-home/HA-3212996998" class="class="static-page-link"">Cheerful 3 bedroom home</a> <a href="/property/country-inn-suites-by-radisson-springfield-oh/BC-277249" class="class="static-page-link"">Country Inn &amp; Suites by Radisson, Springfield, OH</a> <a href="/property/tru-by-hilton-huber-heights-dayton/BC-5026685" class="class="static-page-link"">Tru By Hilton Huber Heights Dayton</a> <a href="/property/hampton-inn-suites-dayton-vandalia/BC-41891" class="class="static-page-link"">Hampton Inn &amp; Suites Dayton-Vandalia</a> <a href="/property/willow-wing-condo-spotless-modern-minutes-to-wpafb-wsu/HA-3214540054" class="class="static-page-link"">Willow Wing Condo -Spotless, Modern &amp; Minutes to WPAFB &amp; WSU</a>

How many pet-friendly vacation rentals are available in New Carlisle on Rentthecottages?

There are more than 82 pet-friendly rentals available on Rentthecottages. Check prices and availability in New Carlisle and last updated on January 2026. Check an individual property if they have restrictions on the size or numbers of pets.

Which is the best dog-friendly place to stay in New Carlisle?

There are many dog-friendly vacation homes available in New Carlisle. Here are the most popular pet-friendly places, ranked by their guest rating as listed in New Carlisle: Blue Dream in Yellow Springs: hot tub, sauna, fireplace. Near downtown. The Wildflower House Yellow Springs AND Pet Friendly Red Roof Inn Springfield, OH Yellow Spring’s Estate on 68 + Pet Friendly

Do you have any luxury vacation homes that allow pets in or near New Carlisle?

Most definitely! There are many luxury places to stay in New Carlisle. Use our search filter to discover all of our luxury accommodations where pets are welcome, then choose the one that matches your taste. Sorting by price is another way to find the most expensive dog-friendly home in New Carlisle. Though note, more expensive is not always better.