Rent The Cottages - Vacation Rentals in Theatre Three

Dates

Price

Guests

More

When do you want to travel?

We search multiple sites to find you the best prices.

Compare Price with Other Partners

From US $524

         

10.0 (18 Reviews)

House

Historic home walking distance to downtown, the harbor, and restaurants!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• New York
• Port Jefferson

View Availability

From US $346

         

New

House

Blue Cottage East Setauket

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• East Setauket

View Availability

From US $168

         

|

8.4 (1009 Reviews)

Hotel

Danfords Hotel and Marina

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• New York
• Port Jefferson

View Availability

From US $671

         

10.0 (8 Reviews)

Cottage

A Hidden Gem! Cozy Cottage with huge Pool & Garden! 8 guest - 4 bedrooms-2 baths

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Port Jefferson Station

View Availability

From US $298

         

|

7.8 (326 Reviews)

Hotel

Danfords Hotel & Marina

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Wheelchair Accessible

• New York
• Port Jefferson

View Availability

From US $1,109

         

New

Villa

Spacious 5-bedroom villa in pleasant Setauket- East Setauket with WiFi, AC

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• New York
• East Setauket

View Availability

From US $598

         

10.0 (3 Reviews)

House

Blue Cottage East Setauket

• Air Conditioner
• Security/Safety
• Fireplace/Heating

• New York
• East Setauket

View Availability

From US $170

         

4.6 (64 Reviews)

Hotel

Americas Best Value Inn - Port Jefferson Station - Long Island -New York - 11776

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Security/Safety

• New York
• Port Jefferson Station

View Availability

From US $268

         

10.0 (3 Reviews)

Apartment

Historic Beautifully Preserved 1800’s Retreat - Large 1bd Apt in PJ Village

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Port Jefferson

View Availability

From US $910

         

10.0 (1 Review)

House

Beachfront Home-Fully Furnished. PRIVATE Beach Rights on L.I. Sound.

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Mount Sinai

View Availability

From US $233

         

9.6 (52 Reviews)

Condo

1856 Trading House w/walk to water

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Mount Sinai

View Availability

From US $266

         

9.6 (21 Reviews)

Condo

1856 Trading House close to water

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Mount Sinai

View Availability

From US $3,296

         

New

Villa

Beachfront Mega Mansion

• Air Conditioner
• Pool
• TV

• Port Jefferson
• Belle Terre

View Availability

From US $651

         

New

House

White Cottage East Setauket

• Air Conditioner
• View
• Ocean View

• New York
• East Setauket

View Availability

New

From US $218

         

New

Apartment

Newly done Cozy 1 bedroom basement apartment in Port Jefferson Station

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• New York
• Port Jefferson Station

View Availability

From US $342

         

10.0 (21 Reviews)

House

Cottage Near Cedar Beach

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• New York
• Miller Place

View Availability

From US $1,036

         

2.0 (1 Review)

Villa

Spacious 5-bedroom villa in pleasant Setauket- East Setauket with WiFi, AC

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• East Setauket

View Availability

From US $340

         

New

House

Do not book- Port Jefferson!

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• Security/Safety

• New York
• Port Jefferson

View Availability

From US $299

         

10.0 (11 Reviews)

House

Harborside Serenity

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• East Setauket
• Poquott

View Availability

From US $582

         

8.8 (5 Reviews)

Bed & Breakfast

The Fox and Owl Inn - Victorian B&B for Contemporary Travelers

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pool

• New York
• Port Jefferson

View Availability

From US $7,500

         

New

House

Atlantis Manor: Luxury Beachfront Mega Mansion

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• Pool

• Port Jefferson
• Belle Terre

View Availability

From US $2,500

         

New

Villa

Luxury Retreat Getaway

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• Pool

• Port Jefferson
• Belle Terre

View Availability

From US $1,065

         

New

Villa

Ocean House 5-bedroom private beach villa

• Air Conditioner
• Security/Safety
• Bedding/Linens

• New York
• Mount Sinai

View Availability

From US $563

         

New

House

Charming 2-bedroom townhome in Port Jefferson Its a Hop Skip and a jump to town

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Port Jefferson

View Availability

★ Pro Tip: Rentthecottages makes it easy to compare the best listings on Rentthecottages homes from online vacation rental OTAs, including Booking.com and more. Use the Advanced Filter feature at the top to easily flip between Rentthecottages homes, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, private Airbnb-style rentals availability, eco-friendly properties, property type, cancellation policies, prices, and several different options. All these make it easier to find the perfect accommodation for your next vacation in Theatre Three.